What happens when our students enter a world where AI can solve the problems we’ve spent years teaching them to solve? The real challenge won’t be finding the right answer. It will be navigating messy problems filled with competing priorities, incomplete information, unintended consequences, and human needs that don’t fit neatly into a formula.
In my latest article, I explore what it means to design messy problems that help students develop the skills they'll need in an unpredictable world.
Students Exploring Messy Problems
I’m a huge fan of student-led sessions in conferences because we often get the nuance, honesty, and contextual elements that are sometimes missing from broader sessions on big topics. So, I’m sitting in a circle of chairs in a session on work-based learning. This is one of the rare conferences where I am not leading multiple sessions. Just a keynote and then a chance to learn from a diverse group of educators (or in this case, students).
At one point, we break into small groups and one of the students leads us in a scenario-based activity. I don’t remember it verbatim but the gist is this: you are working a construction project and the bags are really heavy. A few hours into the first day, you are feeling exhausted and sore. You’re not sure if you should talk to fellow workers or your supervisor. You want to make a good first impression but you also need to advocate for yourself. What should you do?
I love this problem because it doesn’t have a simple solution. Each potential answer actually leads to multiple potential consequences. It’s nuanced. This might be a chance to challenge unethical working conditions but also there’s a need to learn the trade and work within the system where you are essentially powerless.
Each scenario is like this. One deals with co-workers giving you a nickname that you don’t appreciate but it’s also part of the company culture. Another deals with someone who is immature and perhaps even reckless asking for a letter of recommendation.
As each small group discusses their potential solutions, I am struck by the difference between these solutions and many of the problems students solve in school. Here, the answer is not immediate. It requires nuance and complexity. It taps into human interactions and could potentially require contextual understanding and empathy.
What Problems Are We Solving?
I remember sitting in a high school math class trying to solve a problem involving two trains leaving different stations at different speeds. At what point would they meet? I may have been a bit neurospicy, but not the kind who loves trains. I simply didn’t care about the trains. I didn’t know anyone on the trains. I had no idea why they were leaving at different times or why it was my job to figure out when they would meet.
Years later, as a teacher, I remember my students working on a problem where someone was buying an ungodly amount of watermelon based on how many watermelons their neighbor had purchased. Why was this person buying so much watermelon? What kind of fruit-based party would require fourteen watermelons? Why did their neighbor’s watermelon purchases matter? Who eats that much watermelon? And what are the unintended consequences of that much sugar and fiber?
Both problems had a clear process and a single correct answer. And while students certainly need to learn the mathematical concepts involved, I wonder what happens when we reduce problem-solving to a series of disconnected scenarios where the goal is simply to find the right answer.
It had me thinking about word problems in general. We often think students disengage because of language. So we front-load the vocabulary. We teach decoding techniques. Which is fine. They have a place. But . . . what if the bigger issue is with the problem itself.
We hate stories that go nowhere. It’s a bit like watching Twin Peaks. I know there’s a general mystery but it’s so abstract I can’t follow it. They hate stories that don’t operate the way our world actually operates. This is why I hate Hallmark Movies. They’re predictable and formulaic and they don’t actually tie into the way conflict and complexity play out in our world.
Meanwhile, I actually think students love solving real problems. The type of problems that reflect authentic contexts and invite us to delve into nuance and complexity. And these are the exact kinds of problems our students will need to solve in a world of smart machines.
The term wicked problems emerged in the field of urban planning in the 1960s and was later formalized by design theorists Horst Rittel and Melvin Webber in 1973. They used the term to describe complex social challenges that couldn’t be solved through traditional, linear problem-solving approaches. These were the nuanced, complex problems that required deeper empathy and contextual understanding.
Unlike a traditional math problem with a single correct answer, wicked problems are difficult to define and even harder to solve. They often involve competing priorities, incomplete information, interconnected systems, and unintended consequences. A solution that works for one group might create new problems for another. In fact, attempting to solve one part of a wicked problem can actually change the nature of the problem itself. These challenges require more than simply applying a formula or following a set of steps. They require us to navigate uncertainty, consider multiple perspectives, and make decisions when no solution is perfect.
As they solve these problems, they gain key skills that they'll use throughout the rest of their lives:
Read the Full Article
You can find the full article here. If you find it helpful, please consider sharing it on social media.
Let's Work Together!
I would love to work with your school, district, or conference! You might be interested in keynotes or workshops on deeper learning, PBL for all students, and empowering students and improving student agency
I currently have some dates open in January and February and later in the spring (though my calendar is filling up). I'd also love to do something more in-depth throughout the school year and summer.
My workshops include access to my self-paced courses so participants can continue their professional learning after the day's event.
Please reach out to me at john@spencereducation.com or fill out the form on my speaking page, and I'll get back to you as soon as possible. I can send you a PD catalog with all the details.