PBL by Design: Exploring the Overlap of Project-Based Learning and Design Thinking


Project-based learning and design thinking have both become buzzwords in the educational landscape. But beyond the buzz, both PBL and design thinking have rich histories that span decades. Both approaches also offer practical frameworks for teachers who are crafting authentic projects for their students.

So, what exactly is the relationship between PBL and design thinking? When and how should we use each approach? Is either option better for our students? In this article, we explore what it means to find the overlap between PBL and design thinking by treating project-based learning as the pedagogical framework and design thinking as the creative framework.

Empowering Students with Voice and Choice

What happens when teachers design projects that empower students with voice and choice? Students embrace a maker mindset. They define themselves as inventors and creators. They learn to take creative risks. Here they experiment and engage in iterative thinking. When this happens, they embrace a growth mindset and grow resilient. They become problem solvers and systems thinkers. They become divergent thinkers — thinking outside the box. They use creative constraint to find original uses for materials. Here, they discover it’s okay to be different. Often students embrace curiosity and wonder. They become explorers seeking out new information and thinking critically. They grow more empathetic as they design meaningful products that they launch to the world.

On an academic level, students are more engaged and the information sticks. There’s often an increase in student achievement. Meanwhile, they learn key skills like project management, collaboration, and communication. True, these projects will prepare students for the creative economy. But more importantly, they empower students for a creative life. Here, they see that making is magic. We know that there’s a time crunch in schools. Materials can be scarce. Sometimes you’re stuck with a tight curriculum map. But when you, as a teacher, empower your students with voice and choice, they become the makers who change the world.

But how do we make the most out of project-based learning when we have tight time deadlines, a set of standards to teach, and limited resources? One solution is to combine project-based learning with design thinking. You can think of PBL as a pedagogical framework and design thinking as a creative framework. When this happens, you end up with PBL by Design. It’s an idea I explore in my latest sketch video:

But it has me thinking about this idea of creative habits and the bigger notion of creative momentum. So, I want to share an older blog post. I didn't write a new one this week, in part because I just finished my first draft on my novel. And after hitting 65k words, I didn't feel like writing about education.

video preview​

Read the Full Article

You can find the full article here. If you find it helpful, please consider sharing it on social media.

Listen to the Podcast

You can also listen to my latest podcast episode by subscribing to the Creative Classroom Podcast on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. The feed might take a moment to update, so if this episode isn't showing up, I promise it will! I took a little break but I'm back. :)

If you enjoy my podcast, would you consider leaving a review?

Let's Work Together!

I would love to work with your school, district, or conference! You might be interested in keynotes or workshops on deeper learning, PBL for all students, and empowering students and improving student agency

I currently have some dates open in January and February and later in the spring (though my calendar is already pretty full). I'd also love to do something more in-depth throughout the school year and summer.

My workshops include access to my self-paced courses so participants can continue their professional learning after the day's event.

Please reach out to me at john@spencereducation.com or fill out the form on my speaking page, and I'll get back to you as soon as possible. I can send you a PD catalog with all the details.

Dr. John Spencer

​Facebook - Instagram - YouTube - LinkedIn​

John Spencer

Dr. John Spencer is the author of The AI Roadmap, Vintage Innovation, Empower, and Launch. He creates blog posts, articles, and free resources about creativity, project-based learning, deeper learning, and tech integration. Join his free newsletter to get exclusive free access to the ideas, tools, and resources that can help you empower your students.

Read more from John Spencer

I have a tradition of working on a new fiction project every year. I start on September 11th and go until the end of the year. It was something I started on 9-11 when I felt overwhelmed by the useless sense of destruction and the repeating loop of the tragedy on tv, so I sat down and started working on a novel. I rarely publish these works. It's mostly for me and maybe a few close friends. But it has me thinking about this idea of creative habits and the bigger notion of creative momentum....

We often assume that creativity requires freedom. Remove the rules, open up the possibilities, and let students run with their ideas. But sometimes the opposite is true. The right constraints can give us a starting point, push us beyond the obvious, and lead to possibilities we might never have considered on our own. In my latest article, I explore why constraints can fuel creativity and how we can use them intentionally in the classroom. This is my third article in a series I'm calling...

Sometimes our biggest creative failures reveal what we actually believe about creativity. In my second article in my series I'm calling Routine Creativity, I tell the story of a disastrous California Mission project and how one teacher transformed this epic fail into something that was far more authentic and meaningful for me at the time. This revised project forced me to rethink what it means to be a creative thinker. Years later, I can see how many of my assumptions were actually common...